Research

NMES fatigue was not explained by lifting experience

By

In short

Across ten NMES contractions, force decline averaged 49.1% in trained adults and 52.7% in untrained adults, without a significant status effect. SBP generated higher peak force than Russian current, but no significant fatigue advantage.

Lifting experience did not significantly explain the percentage decline in electrically elicited quadriceps force. This experiment involved 20 young adults, ten resistance-trained and ten untrained, with a mean age of 23±2 years. Thirteen were male and seven female. It examined the dominant quadriceps during one set per waveform, not months of adaptation, gym performance or whether electrical stimulation helps someone recover from training.

What did the fatigue percentage actually measure?

Participants received ten contractions using each of two waveforms: Russian current and symmetrical biphasic pulsed current, or SBP. Fatigue response was the percentage force decrease between the highest and lowest repetitions within that set. The definition does not say that the final contraction was always the lowest. It also does not mean that squat capacity fell by half. Electrically elicited force is a different task from a voluntarily completed lift.

Read mean differences separately from statistical evidence
ComparisonMean resultSignificance
Training status: fatigueTrained 49.1%; untrained 52.7%P=0.475
Waveform: fatigueRussian 55%; SBP 47%P=0.111
Waveform: peak elicited forceSBP 40.57 lb; Russian 17.9 lbP<0.001

Does more peak force mean less fatigue?

SBP produced significantly greater peak elicited force, but waveform did not significantly affect the fatigue percentage. Training status did not significantly affect peak force either: averages were 29.9 lb in trained participants and 28.5 lb in untrained participants, with P=0.838. These outcomes answer separate questions. Do not assume that an experienced lifter tolerates repeated stimulation better, or that SBP reduces fatigue because its mean percentage was lower. Nonsignificant findings in a small sample also fail to prove that the responses are equivalent.

How should stimulation and lifting records stay separate?

  1. If stimulation is used, note the waveform and date separately from ordinary exercise entries.
  2. When force or fatigue measurements are available, preserve their units and calculation method.
  3. Use completed lift 1RM records for the Big Three, without adding electrically elicited force to the total.

These are fairlift diary suggestions. The whole-body EMS trial for kneecap pain studied a different intervention, population and outcome. Its rehabilitation findings cannot be imported into this single-set quadriceps comparison. The present experiment establishes neither pain relief nor hypertrophy. A Muscle Index score likewise cannot evaluate the output of a stimulation device.

The abstract does not provide the detailed settings needed for an individual stimulation prescription. A waveform's higher elicited force is not an instruction to buy a device or raise its intensity yourself.

Frequently asked questions

Were trained adults less fatigued during NMES?

Mean force decline was 49.1% in trained adults and 52.7% in untrained adults, but training status was not significant (P=0.475). This small experiment also does not prove equivalent responses.

Did SBP reduce fatigue compared with Russian current?

Mean fatigue was 47% with SBP and 55% with Russian current, without a significant waveform effect (P=0.111). SBP's higher peak force is a separate result.

Can electrically elicited force count toward a Big Three record?

Electrically elicited force is not a voluntarily completed lift 1RM. Keep the waveform and force units separately rather than adding the value to the Big Three or Muscle Index.

Source: PubMed (published )

Calculate your strength score →

Enter your Big 3 lifts and bodyweight for a relative strength score corrected for age and height. Free, no account needed.

Keep reading