Recovery

Plantar pain: procedure had no proven exercise advantage

By

In short

In refractory plantar fasciopathy, a trial analyzed 72 of 82 randomized patients. The six-month pain-change gap was −4.9 points (95% CI −13.8 to 4.0). Microtenotomy showed no superiority over heavy-slow exercise; equivalence was not tested.

Radiofrequency microtenotomy did not produce a statistically superior six-month pain result to heavy-slow resistance exercise in people with refractory plantar fasciopathy. This was a treatment-choice trial for persistent symptoms, a different question from choosing stretches for a sore heel. Eighty-two patients were randomized and 72 entered the final analysis; 74% of those analyzed were women. The primary endpoint was change in the pain domain of the Danish Foot Health Status Questionnaire, or FHSQ-DK.

What did the comparison measure?

ItemRadiofrequency microtenotomyHeavy-slow resistance
ApproachMinimally invasive procedureSelf-dosed exercise programme
Primary six-month comparisonChange in FHSQ-DK pain scoreNo significant between-group gap
Patients reporting adverse eventsFourFive

The mean difference in pain-score change was −4.9 points, with a 95% confidence interval from −13.8 to 4.0. Because that interval includes zero, it does not support superiority of the procedure. It is a questionnaire-point difference, not a 4.9% reduction in pain. The supplied abstract gives no baseline and final group scores, so it cannot establish how much each group improved on its own. A superiority test also cannot turn a nonsignificant result into proof that the treatments have equal effects.

Were all other outcomes and harms identical?

Other questionnaire domains, activity measures and global perceived effect did not differ between groups, with an exception for perceived ability to perform sports at one month (P<0.05). The abstract does not supply the direction or magnitude of that exception. No serious adverse events were observed, but four procedure patients and five exercise patients reported adverse events. Those counts matter: absence of serious events in this sample does not make either option risk-free.

What can a training diary contribute?

  1. Record the load, repetitions and dates of the programme agreed with the treating professional.
  2. Keep symptoms and changes in standing, walking and sports participation in a separate note.
  3. Mark changes in lower-body training during the same period so treatment and training can be reviewed together.

This is a fairlift application, not a reconstruction of the intervention. The abstract does not give exact loads, sets or tempo, so it cannot justify inventing a calf-raise protocol. The plantar-fascia stretching guide addresses a separate question. Likewise, an increase in the Muscle Index is a lifting outcome, not evidence that heel pain has resolved or that heavy lifting is cleared.

These were refractory cases, not every new episode of heel pain. Diagnosis, treatment selection and tolerated exercise need individual assessment. Failure to show superiority is not a demonstration of equivalence.

Frequently asked questions

Was the radiofrequency procedure more effective than exercise?

It showed no significant advantage in six-month FHSQ-DK pain-score change. The mean difference was −4.9 points, with a 95% confidence interval of −13.8 to 4.0.

Does that mean the treatments are equal and have no adverse effects?

A nonsignificant superiority result does not establish equivalence. No serious adverse events were observed, but four procedure patients and five exercise patients reported adverse events.

Can I reproduce the exercise programme from the abstract?

The abstract describes self-dosed heavy-slow resistance without exact loads, sets or tempo. Agree on a specific programme and return criteria with the treating professional.

Source: PubMed (published )

Calculate your strength score →

Enter your Big 3 lifts and bodyweight for a relative strength score corrected for age and height. Free, no account needed.

Keep reading