Training

RIR logging needs the scale beside the number

By

In short

In 32 people lifting at 75% 1RM, RIR and Borg-RPE showed no significant difference in failure-proximity prediction accuracy. That does not prove equivalence or small errors. Log the assessment scale alongside load and reps.

Neither RIR nor Borg-RPE had a statistically significant advantage in predicting proximity to failure during machine chest presses and leg extensions. The practical issue for a training diary is still unresolved by a bare number: a note reading ‘2’ or ‘8’ does not tell the next reader what was assessed. Record the method as well as the score, so an apparent change in effort does not hide a change in scales.

What did the comparison actually test?

The randomized crossover study involved 32 participants: 19 trained and 13 untrained. They performed both exercises at 75% of one-repetition maximum in two experimental sessions, with session and exercise order randomized. During each set they called out when they believed they had reached 2 RIR or Borg-RPE 8, then continued to momentary failure. Accuracy was calculated from the difference between repetitions actually remaining at the call and the number predicted. Continuing to failure supplied a measurement reference; it was not a test of whether every training set should end there.

Between-method accuracy differences, not absolute prediction errors
ExerciseMean difference (reps)95% confidence intervalp value
Chest press−0.03−0.50 to 0.440.893
Leg extension0.16−0.39 to 0.710.556

Does a nonsignificant gap make the scales interchangeable?

No significant difference is not proof of equivalence. The chest-press value of −0.03 repetitions does not mean that people missed the true remaining count by only 0.03 repetitions. It describes a comparison between methods, and the supplied abstract does not give each method's absolute error. Training status did not influence the difference in accuracy between methods. That narrower finding does not establish that beginners and experienced lifters have identical estimation skills in every setting.

What belongs beside load and repetitions?

  1. Write down the exercise, load and completed repetition count.
  2. Label the effort estimate as RIR or with the specific RPE scale you used.
  3. Compare entries using the same method for the same exercise, and mark any change in assessment scale.

These are fairlift diary suggestions, rather than a logging intervention evaluated by the trial. An exercise note can preserve the method without pretending that a machine effort score is a Big 3 one-rep maximum or a Muscle Index result. If the weight and repetitions stay unchanged but the assessment method changes, the score alone cannot show a gain in strength. Keeping the label makes later comparisons easier to interpret without inventing a conversion between scales. Read about practicing RIR estimates; use the Muscle Index calculator for completed lift records.

Borg-RPE 8 in this study must not be substituted for the lifting convention ‘RPE 8 = 2 RIR.’ The experiment tested two machine exercises at 75% 1RM; it does not establish a conversion rule, results for all barbell lifts, or a prescription to take every set to failure.

Frequently asked questions

Was RIR more accurate than Borg-RPE?

The 32-participant machine chest-press and leg-extension experiment found no significant accuracy difference between methods. The supplied abstract does not report each method's absolute error, so it cannot establish how small those errors were.

Does Borg-RPE 8 in this study mean 2 RIR?

The study used 2 RIR and Borg-RPE 8 as separate judgment targets, without establishing a conversion between them. Its Borg-RPE score should not be read as the conventional lifting-RPE meaning of 8.

How can I use this in a fairlift workout diary?

Add the RIR or specific RPE scale label beside load and repetitions. Compare entries with the same method and exercise conditions, and keep machine effort scores separate from Big 3 1RM and Muscle Index records.

Source: PubMed (published )

Calculate your strength score →

Enter your Big 3 lifts and bodyweight for a relative strength score corrected for age and height. Free, no account needed.

Keep reading